Horseshoe Lake
Otter Tail County, Minnesota, near Phelps. DNR lake ID 56045500.
Horseshoe Lake is a 147-acre lake in Otter Tail County, Minnesota, near Phelps. Summer water clarity averages 2.9 feet in Minnesota Pollution Control Agency monitoring. It is not on the DNR infested waters list as of September 2026.
Buying or selling on Horseshoe Lake? Ask us what lakeshore here actually sells for, which stretches of shoreline buyers compete for, and what’s coming up before it’s listed.
Tell us about your dream home on Horseshoe LakeWhat’s my Horseshoe Lake property worth?Call (218) 656-6469
Quick facts
| DNR lake ID | 56045500 |
|---|---|
| County | Otter Tail County, near Phelps |
| Surface area | 147 acres |
| Maximum depth | Not surveyed |
| Share under 15 ft | Not surveyed |
| Water clarity (summer) | 2.9 ft through 2025 (satellite estimate) |
| Invasive species | Not on DNR infested waters list (Sept 2026) |
| Public water accesses | 0 |
Water quality
Summer averages from Minnesota Pollution Control Agency monitoring through 2025: clarity 2.9 ft.
Fishing regulations
No lake-specific regulation found in Minnesota Rules or the DNR sunfish list. Statewide and zone regulations apply.
Regulations change. Confirm with the DNR before fishing.
Invasive species
Not on the Minnesota DNR infested waters list as of September 2026. That means no confirmed listing, not a guarantee the lake is free of invasive species.
Public boat access
No public water access on DNR record.
Nearby lakes
- East Lost Lake 1.6 mi, Otter Tail County
- Crooked Lake 1.7 mi, Otter Tail County
- Deer Lake 2.2 mi, Otter Tail County
- North Turtle Lake 2.2 mi, Otter Tail County
- Mud Lake 2.3 mi, Otter Tail County
- Anna Lake 2.9 mi, Otter Tail County
- Brown Lake 2.9 mi, Otter Tail County
- Round Lake 3.0 mi, Otter Tail County
Questions about Horseshoe Lake
How big is Horseshoe Lake?
Horseshoe Lake covers about 147 acres in Otter Tail County, Minnesota.
How clear is Horseshoe Lake?
Summer water clarity on Horseshoe Lake averages 2.9 feet (Secchi depth) in MPCA monitoring through 2025.
Does Horseshoe Lake have zebra mussels or other invasive species?
Horseshoe Lake is not on the Minnesota DNR infested waters list as of September 2026. That means there is no confirmed listing; it is not a guarantee the lake is free of invasive species.
Are there lake homes for sale on Horseshoe Lake?
Homes on Horseshoe Lake come up for sale throughout the year, and some sell before they’re ever publicly advertised. Tell us what you’re looking for and our agents will run a custom search and send you matching homes on Horseshoe Lake and nearby lakes, including off-market opportunities when available.
What is it like to live on Horseshoe Lake?
Small, quiet water suited to paddling and fishing, and summer clarity around 2.9 feet. Conditions vary by property, so walk the frontage and ask us what similar homes have sold for.
Are there special fishing regulations on Horseshoe Lake?
No lake-specific regulation was found for Horseshoe Lake in Minnesota Rules or the DNR sunfish list. Statewide and zone regulations apply.
Ask us about Horseshoe Lake
Whether you’re buying, selling, or just curious, our team works Otter Tail County lakes every day. Send us a note or call (218) 656-6469.
Sources: Minnesota DNR LakeFinder records, DNR fish surveys (latest not on record), DNR infested waters list (Sept 2026), Minnesota Rules 6264.0400 (April 2026), MPCA monitoring via the Water Quality Portal, DNR water access records (2023), LAGOS-US. Lakewide information from public data; it does not describe any specific property. Verify shoreline, bottom type, and depth at any frontage.